James Titterton, Bouvines 1214 (Osprey, 2025)
You might think that the purpose of a military campaign is to bring the enemy to battle and defeat him. That was not the case in 13th Century Europe: campaigns were designed to coerce the enemy preferably without risking everything on a single engagement. But sometimes battles happen as when French king Philippe II Augustus turned to fight a coalition army at Bouvines, reshaping the destiny of three European dynasties and that of Europe. Medieval historian James Titterton is our guide to that battle in the latest volume of Osprey’s Campaign series.
Titterton first considers the commanders for the 1214 campaign. England’s King John was a capable military commander but politically inept. His ally, Otto IV, the Holy Roman Emperor, was a ruler in political decline and beset by dynastic conflict at home. They led a coalition of European nobles with axes to grind. Their opponent was Philippe II Augustus, the ‘ascendant power in Europe’, a severe and pious man who was also a ‘bold and dynamic’ general, according to Titterton. He was assisted by ‘Brother’ Guérin, bishop-elect of Senlis and an excellent general. Titterton raises the thorny problem of contemporary neutral sources before delving into the plans for each side. The coalition, he notes, was ambitious, with two armies operating in different theatres: King John marching north from La Rochelle, and Otto moving in from the north with no obvious military objective other than to harass Philippe. The French opted for a Fabian approach, avoiding an engagement until the barking Otto caught the truck.
European feudal armies were much the same, argues Titterton, differing mostly in organisation and finance. He then surveys the main components of medieval armies: the knights, mounted serjeants, and foot soldiers, of whom we know next to nothing other than they took the brunt of the vicious fighting that was the hallmark of medieval battles. Despite the general paucity of sources, Titterton notes that the campaign and Battle of Bouvines are well represented, including an accurate order of battle for both sides. The author follows those armies on campaign. John’s campaign in the south followed the typical pattern of raids and sieges, while the northern campaign proved less complex, with both sides making a beeline to Bouvines, where they would meet on 27 July 2014.
Although we do not have a complete picture of the battle, Titterton cobbles together a breathtaking narrative of the Coalition catching the French rearguard on the march, Philippe offering his crown to his nobles as a loyalty test, the French turning to fight, the slowly developing deployment, attacks and counter-attacks, the chaos of battle as ‘a spectacle of violence’, Philippe’s moment of peril, Otto’s flight from the field, and the collapse of the Coalition army. Titterton argues that the Battle of Bouvines decided the fate of three dynasties: Angevin, Capetian, and Welf. Otto all but lost his empire and returned to his estates a humiliated man. The triumphant Philippe turned south to take on King John. The latter, abandoned by his continental barons, had to negotiate a truce, after which he returned to England. The defeat of his coalition led to the signing of the Magna Carta. Philippe became the premier ruler of Europe, and his monarchy shaped the future of France for centuries.
Bouvines 1214 is a tidy introduction to a campaign and battle that is not as well known or understood as it should be. Titterton deftly handles the often difficult task of narrating a medieval battle, and his contextual material covers all the relevant factors. He also supplies a very useful list of books for further reading, reinforcing the idea of this book acting as a gateway into the period, as so many of the Osprey Campaign series books do. I was not convinced by Titterton’s argument on the decisive nature of this battle, but he certainly makes the case for Bouvines as a major catalyst for the fundamental changes that subsequently happened in Europe. Nevertheless, readers with even a passing interest in medieval military history and European history in general will appreciate and enjoy Titterton’s book.
