by RNS | Nov 21, 2023 | Beating Tsundoku
Bruce Oliver Newsome, Valentine Infantry Tank vs Panzer III (Osprey, 2023)
I blame Hollywood. World War II tanks on the big screen tend to be portrayed as behemoth fighting machines, bristling with firepower and guaranteeing death and destruction on a grand scale. In reality, those tanks were few and far between; rather, most tanks on both sides were relatively small and nimble, performing multiple battlefield tasks. Bruce Newsome examines two of those tanks from the early war and how they clashed in North Africa.
Newsome notes right off the bat that Panzer IIIs and Valentines constituted one-quarter of German and British tank production, though both underwent numerous upgrades as the war proceeded. Newsome narrates the design and development of both tanks, their specifications, production (6,094 Panzer IIIs, 7,260 Valentines), and deployment in various theatres through August 1944. It is North Africa, however, and in particular Tunisia, where Newsome focuses his attention. He surveys the strategic situation and planning with box-outs for the main commanders. Then Newsome revisits the technical aspects of the tanks, including the roles of the crew members. Newsome returns to Tunisia to describe, quite extensively for an Osprey book of this nature, the battles around Tebourba in November-December 1942 and the lessons both sides gained from them.
This book should appeal to World War II tank enthusiasts. Newsome regularly flips between the two tanks so that the reader gets a genuine sense of comparative parallel development. That also prevents the less technically educated reader from becoming bogged down, making for a solid introductory book in keeping with Osprey’s overall mission for this Duel series. The battles Newsome chooses are explained to a high enough degree to give a sense of what tank combat in North Africa was all about; a more nuanced event than your average Hollywood tank movie offers. The accompanying photographs and graphic art compliment Newsome’s text, as we come to expect from Osprey. Overall, this is recommended for modellers, wargamers, and novice readers to tank warfare.
by RNS | Nov 2, 2023 | Beating Tsundoku
Pier Paolo Battistelli, The Winter Campaign in Italy 1943 (Osprey, 2023)
A new volume in Osprey’s Campaign series takes us to some intense combat as the Allies pushed their way up the Italian peninsula at the end of 1943. It’s October, and the Allies are intent on capturing Rome, while the Germans drew lines on the map and determined to defend them. One of those lines, the Bernhardt Line, was designated the Winter Line by the Allies, and they expected to breach it by Christmas 1943. They didn’t. In this book, Pier Battistelli tells you why.
After a brief chronology, Battistelli provides biographies of some of the opposing commanders, which is not very useful in the context of this book but at least you know who they were. The composition of the opposing forces that comes next is more on track. We find the Allies undermanned and relying on firepower to break through the Axis defences, while the Germans struggled with manpower too but had the advantage of terrain. Battistelli next considers the opposing plans; the Allies fixated on the bauble that was Rome, and the Germans determined to defend their lines south of Rome at all costs, though that was not without argument at the highest levels with a defence north of Rome favoured by some.
Battistelli begins his campaign coverage with the Allies approaching the Winter Line and the Germans falling back into prepared positions. The Americans then probed the Winter Line, leading to the costly battles for San Pietro in December 1943. Meanwhile, the British 8th Army crossed the Sangro, and the New Zealand 2nd Division attempted to take Orsogna, again into the teeth of fierce opposition. They would not succeed despite numerous attempts. Battistelli’s account switches to the advance from the Moro River on the road to Ortona, this time with the Canadians at the forefront. It would take a week for them to capture the town in what Battistelli suggests was an unnecessary operation. In the aftermath, the Allies landed at Anzio and the epic battle of Monte Cassino began, lasting for months. A brief glance at the battlefields today and an interesting Further Reading section close out Battistelli’s book.
The Italian campaign is mostly remembered for the battles of Monte Cassino and Anzio, so this book’s overview of the fighting before those momentous events is a welcome addition to the Osprey stable. Battistelli does a good job of covering this period, ably assisted by Osprey’s usual excellent maps and contemporary photographs. It is a gateway book with limited room for detailed text, as you might expect with Osprey, so it is difficult not to go beyond the operational aspects of who did what, where, and when. However, Battistelli gives the reader a flavour of this gruelling campaign and points the way forward to further reading. You can’t ask for much more than that.
by RNS | Oct 27, 2023 | Beating Tsundoku
Gregg Adams, Japanese Infantryman versus US Marine Rifleman (Osprey, 2023)
An atoll is an almost flat, ring-shaped coral reef encircling a lagoon. There are many of them in the Pacific Ocean, but they barely trouble mapmakers. The Japanese found them useful as forward bases for air and sea operations, however, and dug elaborate defences out of almost nothing. It was up the United States Marine Corps to take these atolls, fighting yard by sandy yard. Gregg Adams highlights three American assaults on atolls to illustrate how these two determined enemies locked horns in a desperate struggle for tactical and strategic supremacy.
Adams examines the fighting on the Tarawa, Roi-Namur, and Eniwetok atolls in the Gilberts and Marshall Islands. From late 1942, the Japanese fortified these islands as part of their strategic defence. By October 1943, the US Navy was strong enough to take the offensive in the Gilbert Islands with Tarawa as the first target for a Marine landing. After that victory, they attacked the Marshall Islands in February 1944. Adams reviews the opposing sides and their doctrines. That includes US amphibious warfare, which was more complicated than it looks in the movies and newsreels! For the Japanese defenders, they had to dig in, counterattack, and sacrifice when necessary. Adams next surveys the structure of both sides; we find the US Marine Corps up against a variety of Japanese units, including civilian units that were still required to fight. Then we are into the actions on Betio Island, Tarawa Atoll; Namur Island, Kwajalein Atoll; and Engebi Island, Eniwetok Atoll. These accounts are accompanied by many photographs showing shattered palm trees and buildings, and Marines trying to make best use of whatever cover they can find under fire from the hidden Japanese. In his analysis of this peculiar combat, Adams notes that the Americans had to learn as they went from atoll to atoll, developing new weapons and tactics. The Japanese learned almost nothing, partly from believing that what they were doing would work; a misplaced optimism as it turned out. Adams highlights the plight of Japanese garrisons increasingly isolated on other atolls as the Americans swept past them on their next mission.
It somewhat boggles the mind that men were sent into combat on these heavily defended little atolls. Adams demonstrates, however, that far from being crass assaults there was planning and method behind them, and the US studied each attack before launching the next one. There were also not many options when the defenders refused to surrender. Adams is ably assisted by Osprey’s usual artwork, and the book as a whole is a satisfying and illuminating read.
by RNS | Oct 21, 2023 | Beating Tsundoku
Paul L Dawson, Fighting Napoleon at Home (Frontline, 2023)
Historical wars were seldom as popular as later ‘patriots’ would have you believe. All wars have dissenters, some against the war on principle, some who are opportunists furthering their causes. When wars coincide with economic and political crises at home, that dissent can turn revolutionary. If you follow Paul Dawson’s thesis on unrest in Britain during the Revolutionary and Napoleonic Wars, you will see how close Britain came to an epoch-changing revolution.
BUY NOW
Dawson sets up a dichotomy between Loyalists and Radical reformers that came into political conflict during the American Revolution. Many of the Radicals in that war continued their opposition into the Napoleonic Wars via the French Revolution. Loyalists, such as Edmund Burke, were vehemently opposed to events in France, inspiring actions against reformers. Undaunted, notes Dawson, the reformers established Jacobin clubs, particularly in the new urban, industrial centres. As they grew in popularity and became a perceived threat to the establishment, these clubs were soon infiltrated by Loyalist spies. Loyalists formed groups too, then came government oppression under the guise of fighting sedition. Free speech was curtailed along with the free press, and with the power of the judiciary against them, there was little the reformers could do. Loyalists also hounded reformer Thomas Paine out of the country, burning him in effigy. Dawson follows the career of noted Radical Henry Redhead Yorke who operated mostly out of Sheffield. Yorke would later recant, but before then the Loyalists saw him as a clear threat along with other Radicals. When the reformers were linked to a French-backed revolution in Ireland and armed rebellion in England, the government acted by rounding up Radicals on charges of high treason.
In 1795, loyalists formed volunteer military units to ‘aid magistrates in clamping down on radical societies’, according to Dawson. This came at a time of high unemployment and food shortages, leading to riots. The government introduced the 1795 Gagging Acts as retribution. Subsequent treason trials resulted in a split amongst reformers, leaving a hard core of Radicals. They formed the United Englishmen, a secretive group with radical links to France and the United Irishmen movement. But French inaction in 1796 failed to incite an English revolution. A new wave of repression followed in 1798 in response to alarms over revolutionary fervour in England.
Dawson moves onto Luddism, a movement inspired by the ban on Trade Unions in 1799 along with a ban on reform societies while famine again swept the country. Machine breaking began in 1799 too, then it erupted in 1811 – this is covered in more detail in Dawson’s companion volume, The Battle Against the Luddites (Pen & Sword, 2023). Widespread food riots occurred in 1800, and alarmingly, the Volunteer Corps in Sheffield refused to put down that town’s unrest. Disease accompanied famine and a full scale revolution seemed on the cards. Dawson notes the unpopularity of the war with France in 1801, the same year that the Habeas Corpus Suspension Act expired, and protests intensified into planning for a revolution. Magistrates broke up seditious meetings and made arrests, often with military support. Hopes of widespread revolution faded, however, with falling food prices and no immediate expectation of French support.
Dawson switches to the Despard Coup amidst rising tensions in Ireland and England in 1802. Plans were laid to seize the Tower of London and overthrow the government with the aid of disaffected soldiers, but it never happened. In a show trial, Despard and others were sentenced to death on flimsy evidence. That did not end radical activism but dampened latent enthusiasm for revolution. War broke out with France again in 1803 and protests continued with the possibility of a French landing. Despite a new famine, however, support for the war increased. Dawson concludes by arguing that the French wars were matched on the home front by competing ideologies, a battle for the soul of the nation, that set the scene for a hundred years of working class struggle.
Paul Dawson has written a strident account of political unrest that will surprise many readers fed on a diet of unwavering British opposition to France. Dawson bases his narrative firmly in the primary sources and his thesis is clearly mapped out, though he seems to give too much credit to the accounts of spies who had much to gain from exaggerating the threat posed by Radicals. Without digging too deeply into Dawson’s argument, be prepared for a by-the-book Marxist interpretation, pitching the working class against the ruling elites. That sometimes drifts into polemic, with Dawson outraged at the reaction to political demands we now take for granted and his habit of making historical comparisons with modern events. This book is also somewhat mistitled, with most of the action taking place before the wars against Napoleon. Nevertheless, in exposing the dark underbelly of British politics, Dawson makes an interesting and useful contribution to the history of this important period.
by RNS | Oct 7, 2023 | Beating Tsundoku
Robert Lyman, A War of Empires (Osprey, 2021)
The notion that the Burma campaign in World War II is forgotten has long been dispelled by a series of recent histories. It remains, however, a complex episode and difficult to unravel, with all its competing narratives across a wide range of players. Robert Lyman’s engaging and lucid A War of Empires is therefore a welcome addition to the Burma library.
Lyman is quick to point out that the army that defeated the Japanese in Burma was Indian not British, although the latter played their full part. It was certainly the hubristic British that neglected this portion of their empire when the Japanese army came calling in December 1941. Lyman calls this a ‘dereliction of duty’ for allowing the catastrophe that ensued as the Japanese cut the defending forces to ribbons all the way to the Indian border.
Enter Major General William ‘Bill’ Slim who took command of a Corps then 14 Army, preventing retreat from becoming a disgrace, then built up the Anglo-Indian forces physically and morally so that they could stop, turn, and then defeat the Japanese. They achieved this by reeling the Japanese into a rather foolhardy attack centred on Imphal, repulsed them, then launched a counter-offensive that drove the Japanese back down through Burma in 1945. Along the way, Lyman discusses the regeneration of the Indian army; the problems of command among the Allied commanders, bringing the Chinese and Americans into this equation; the nationalist aspirations of many Burmese and Indians duped into complicity with the Japanese; the long-range, behind the lines efforts of Orde Wingate’s Chindits; the crucial appointment of Louis Mountbatten as Allied Supreme Commander; the stunning stand of the Anglo-Indians at Kohima ridge; the conflict amongst the Japanese command as their fortunes turned; and Slim’s brilliant final campaign against the stubborn and fanatical Japanese resistance. And those are just the highlights in a comprehensive account.
Lyman sums up the Burma campaign in his closing chapter. He castigates the Japanese empire for its cruelty and wantonness in Burma, while arguing that independence from Britain was already in the future, though his evidence for this feels a bit soft. Lyman also argues that the Burma campaign was the birth of Indian independence in which the Indian army played a pivotal role – he concludes that this was an Indian victory won by an Indian army. Countering the usual argument that Burma was a sideshow, Lyman stresses the importance of the Burma campaign for the defeat of Japan.
A War of Empires is an outstanding military history of the Burma campaign. Lyman skilfully untangles the complex web of narratives overlaying what was anything but a straightforward fight. He also artfully balances the action on the ground with the wider competing political interests of Britain, India, China, Japan, and the United States. However, Lyman is not so much Anglo-centric as Slim-centric, though here too he points out Slim’s good fortune at key moments and notes the contributions of others who paved the way to victory. It is Slim’s story, however, that pulls all Lyman’s threads together. Lyman’s concluding analysis is provocative, and some might disagree with aspects of it, but few could argue against Lyman’s elevation of India into the spotlight. All in all, this is an excellent read and a splendid starting point for any student of World War II in the Far East.
