by RNS | May 19, 2021 | Beating Tsundoku
Ian Baxter, H*tl*r’s Panther Tank Battalions 1943-1945 (Pen & Sword, 2020)
In 1943, a new panzer joined the German fight against the Soviet Union, just in time they hoped to stem the rising enemy tide. The Panther with its sloping sides and front became one of the iconic tanks of WWII, performing sterling service despite its persistent mechanical problems. In H*tl*r’s Panther Tank Battalions 1943-1945, expert Ian Baxter takes us with the Panthers into battle.
BUY NOW
The Panthers debuted at the greatest tank battle at Kursk in July 1943. Some did not make it into action because of mechanical problems, many more were rendered inoperative in the maelstrom that was Kursk. The rest performed well against the Soviet T-34s The Panther had proved its value as a weapon, but as a functioning vehicle it left much to be desired. Baxter switches the action to Italy where the terrain limited tank warfare, but the small contingent of Panthers still proved their worth, particularly in defence. We return to the deteriorating Eastern Front in 1944 where the Panthers were used as mobile reserves and in rescue operations. They performed well again, racking up kills, and by then the Panther had undergone many variants trying to fix their problems. Panthers saw action on the western front too when that opened after D-Day in June 1944. By August, 432 Panthers had been pitched into the fight for France. However, Allied air power proved a major problem, and replacement Panther units were poorly trained and disorganized. Few Panthers made it out intact. Their last hurrah was in the Ardennes Offensive, but ultimately here too they were decimated. That situation was echoed on the Eastern Front. Baxter concludes that the Panther had been introduced into the war too late despite being a deadly adversary for the Allies.
While I disagree with Baxter’s conclusion, I still enjoyed his book very much. He describes the actions and organization of the Panther units in a straightforward and readable text and his captions for the abundant photographs add considerably to their value. As for the photographs, they are a nicely balanced selection of Panthers in various situations across the theatres, along with their supporting vehicles – Panther modelers will not be short of inspiration. All in all, this is a solid addition to the Images of War series and a good read for German armour buffs.
by RNS | May 18, 2021 | Beating Tsundoku
Salvador Mafe Huertas and Riccardo Niccoli, Panavia Tornado (Kagero, 2020)
The Panavia Tornado has been a fixture in the skies for forty years, flown by Europe’s top air forces in peace and war. It is a brute of a thing, capable of significant destruction, but also elegant in its way with its smooth lines running across the cockpit and swept wings then back to that massive tail. To see one in action is to want to know more about it. To that end, Salvador Mafe Huertas and Riccardo Niccoli have written a primer for the Tornado complete with many photographs and graphic renderings.
BUY NOW
The authors begin with the development of the Tornado from 1968 as a pan-European project. As they do this, they introduce the main parts and components of the plane. These are described in some detail as you might expect from a book of this type. It is ironic that a fighter-bomber designed for use in the Cold War did not see action until that had ended but was deployed in the decidedly hot wars that followed. Our authors follow the Tornado into the Middle East and Gulf War, the Balkans, Afghanistan, Libya, operations against ISIS, and Syria. The last active RAF Tornados landed at their home base in February 2019, but the durable plane continues in use by other air-forces.
There are other books about the Tornado, but this one does the job as a primer for the plane despite a couple of errors and some glaring omissions – the lack of coverage of Cold War service and just a brief mention of Saudi Tornados. The book is filled with photographs, some of which are superb, and include a balance of RAF, German, and Italian planes. The colour graphic illustrations are excellent (an A4 print of the cover comes with the book), so that if you wanted to build a model, most of your bases will be covered by this book. I think old Tornado crews will enjoy this as will anyone wanting a guide to the plane.
by RNS | May 17, 2021 | Beating Tsundoku
Gabriele Esposito, Wellington’s Infantry British Foot Regiments 1800-1815 (Pen & Sword, 2021)
The British army that fought and defeated the French under Napoleon was arguably the finest in this island’s long military history. Most of us can picture them in their red coats and black hats, facing down the French cavalry charges at Waterloo. But there was more variety in the British army than first meets the eye. To that end, Gabriele Esposito surveys the British infantry of the period in a book replete with colour pictures of the soldiers involved.
BUY NOW
Esposito begins with the Foot Guards where he provides a history of the units and their involvement in the Napoleonic Wars. He describes the Line Infantry next with an emphasis on their organization added to their history and deployment. The peculiarities of the Scottish Regiments are considered before Esposito moves on to the Light Infantry. Royal Veteran Battalions and Fencible Regiments occupy Chapter 5. Esposito turns to British troops abroad, beginning in Canada, then the West Indies, Africa, and Australia, before arriving in India. Sometimes foreigners came to us and served in the British Army. Esposito describes the King’s Dutch Brigade among others, including Maltese, Italians, Greeks, Swiss, and mixed foreign units. The most famous foreign unit was the King’s German Legion, which receives its own chapter. Esposito concludes with a chapter on uniforms and equipment, which were more varied than novice Napoleonic Wars readers might know. Thus headgear, jackets, and coats are described before Esposito lists the facing colours of all the regiments in the army. He returns to describes officer’s rank distinctions, greatcoats, trousers and kilts, then lists regiments that wore ‘peculiar’ uniforms. Esposito adds belts and pouches, and weapons to complete the soldier’s appearance.
It is difficult to assess the audience for Esposito’s sojourn in the Napoleonic Wars. Veteran students of the period will find much to nit-pick in the text, which rarely rises above routine descriptions and shallow conclusions. The contemporary colour plates are interesting, but many of them are not matched to the text, which seems decidedly odd. That they were all derived from the same online source says something about the superficiality of the research and production of this book. Nevertheless, someone new to the period who wants a primer on the British Army will no doubt enjoy it before moving deeper into the subject.
by RNS | May 14, 2021 | Beating Tsundoku
Terry C Treadwell, The Red Baron (Pen & Sword, 2021)
World War I was the first air war, but unlike the war on the ground, fighting in the skies was an individual endeavour where different, but no less deadly, rules applied. The pilot warriors that dueled each other over the trenches fought and died under their own code of conduct. Some became aces and heroes, a few became legends, but there was only one Red Baron: Manfred von Richthofen, the most feared pilot of the war. In this illuminating book, Terry Treadwell offers a photographic insight into Richthofen’s world.
BUY NOW
There are only two chapters in The Red Baron, which is a bit odd. Treadwell begins with the outbreak of WWI to set the scene for the early Manfred von Richthofen to grow into. He entered the war as a cavalry officer followed by a stint in the trenches with the infantry, but the newly introduced Air Service attracted him, and he was soon training as an observer then a pilot. In September 1916, Richthofen joined ace Oswald Boelcke’s fighter squadron and he soon had his first confirmed kill. Richthofen’s rise continued until he led his own squadron in January 1917. By then he was already Germany’s top living ace: German propaganda ensured he was also a household name. He became the Red Baron through painting his aircraft red for recognition, and he encouraged his pilots to individualize their planes too, thus Richthofen’s Flying Circus was born. Richthofen suffered a serious head wound in July 1917. He resumed flying and accumulating more kills, most famously in his red Fokker Triplane, but in April 1918, Richthofen broke his own rule about never flying low over enemy lines and was shot down and killed. Who killed him remains open to debate, but there is no doubt over the regard his enemies held him in when they buried him with full military honours, much to the chagrin of local civilians. Treadwell concludes with a post-mortem description of Richthofen’s death and a list of his victories.
Treadwell’s The Red Baron is one of those books that provides just enough information to taunt the reader into wanting to know more. The author’s text, as he admits, is there to guide the reader, however, through Richthofen’s illustrious career and to accompany the photographs. The book contains many pictures, tightly grouped around Richthofen himself, thereby offering an almost intimate portrait of the Red Baron in that you get the sense of the man as a warrior and leader. In the most poignant photograph, however, you do not see Richthofen, just him flying his triplane into the distance on his last mission. For those interested in the air war in WWI, this is an informative biopic of the greatest pilot to fly in it and an enjoyable evening’s reading.
by RNS | May 12, 2021 | Beating Tsundoku
Rob Collins, Living on the Edge of Empire (Pen & Sword, 2020)
Hadrian’s Wall conjures up images of an imposing barrier cutting across the northern English landscape, populated by stern-faced Roman soldiers prepared for the next barbarian attack. That isn’t completely wrong, but it is not the whole picture: Hadrian’s Wall became a community hub almost from when the Romans laid the first stone. Rob Collins has put together a book full of fascinating photographs of artefacts, illustrating the many facets of military and civilian life along Rome’s most permanent frontier.
Collins divides his book into eight chapters, encompassing all aspects of life along Hadrian’s Wall, and each lavishly illustrated with colour photographs. He starts with communities and homes, from farmsteads to military tents and barracks. This incorporates a little studies on demographics and furniture and lighting. How the people dressed, and their appearance are next, though perishable materials come mostly from the earlier period of the Wall. Some of the jewellery exhibited here is exquisite, but even the mundane artefacts are extraordinary in their way given how they shine a light on people’s everyday lives. What they ate and how they stored food follows, revealing how even this far off frontier was connected to the whole Empire. We should not forget that Hadrian’s Wall was primarily a military installation, and with that in mind, Collins turns to security, both personal and military, including weapons and armour. But the Wall also acted as an economic centre, so implements for trade and administration are covered here, with a section on leisure items included. Religion played a major role in antiquity and for those living on the Wall. Collins covers the full panoply of the Gods and religious practice in this chapter. Then comes a chapter of unknowns; oddities that we are not quite sure as to their function. All good things come to an end, depending on whose side you were on, and Collins’ last chapter surveys artefacts from the last days of the Wall as it transformed into an Anglo-Saxon zone. Appendices on where all the artefacts were found and museums in which you can see them concludes Collin’s book.
Living on the Edge of Empire is more than a collection of photographs of finds from Hadrian’s Wall; it serves as a useful primer to the Wall as a focal point for community life in all its variety. Collins has assembled an impressive range of materials, which reveal that sometimes the most significant finds come from the most commonplace items. Vindolanda features heavily in the array of objects, which is appropriate given how much has been carried out there. That might skew the picture of the whole Wall, but I think there is enough from other sources to provide balance. Collins’ text matches the artefacts in its clarity, with the final result being a neatly organised and illuminating book. If you cannot visit Hadrian’s Wall, this book might be the next best thing.
BUY NOW
